Skip to content
Shenzhen Makers深圳创客

Choosing · 7 min

Choosing a prototyping method: 3D printing vs CNC vs urethane casting

A simple comparison of the three main prototyping methods by speed, cost, strength, look and quantity, plus a quick way to pick the right one for each part.
Next meetup
SZDIY open night (weekly)Details →

Most prototype shops in Shenzhen offer three main methods. Each is best at something different, and many products use all three for different parts.

At a glance

Choosing a prototyping method

3D printingCNC machiningUrethane casting
SpeedFastest (1–4 days)Fast (3–7 days)Slower (7–12 days, needs a master and mold first)
Cost for 1 partLowestMediumHigh (the silicone mold)
Cost for 20 partsMediumMedium–highOften lowest per part
MaterialsResins, nylon, some metalsReal metals and engineering plasticsPolyurethanes that imitate ABS, PC, rubber, clear
StrengthGood (varies by technology)ExcellentGood
Looks like a molded part?With finishing, somewhatWith finishing, yesYes, closest
Best forEarly shapes, complex geometryMetal parts, precise or strong parts10–50 molded-looking plastic parts

(Typical ranges; confirm with shops.)

Pick by the question you're answering

  • "Does the shape and fit work?" → 3D printing. Fast and cheap, and you'll change the design anyway.
  • "Is it strong enough / precise enough / does metal work here?" → CNC machining in the real material.
  • "I need 20 units that look like real products" (for user testing, photos or a small launch) → urethane casting.
  • "I need something rubbery or clear" → casting (or specific print materials).

Mixing methods

A single prototype often combines them: a CNC-machined aluminum frame, SLA-printed buttons, and a cast rubber seal. Prototype shops that offer everything can build and finish the whole assembly together, which saves you coordinating several suppliers.

When to stop prototyping

When the design stops changing between rounds and you need hundreds or thousands of units, it's time to look at production tooling like injection molding.

Next steps

Updated 29 September 2026